Religious views on stem cell research contribute to controversy in medical research. Each religion has a different view of embryonic stem cell research. Due to their different views about the start of life, concerns about stem cell research arise. By understanding different religious beliefs, you can understand the controversy. The controversy may stem from religious beliefs or ethical practices.
Religious Views On Stem Cell Research | What Different Religions Have To Say About Stem Cell Research
When it comes to stem cell research, Catholics believe it is wrong. Catholic views on stem cell research are highly influenced by their understanding of how life begins. Catholic beliefs suggest that life begins at conception. An embryo is a human life, which is why Catholics follow a pro-life view.
Due to their belief in life at conception, a Catholic feels that embryonic stem cell research is a form of murder. To obtain the stem cells, doctors destroy an embryo. Since the embryo is a potential life, they consider the death a murder.
Protestant beliefs differ from Catholics. They do not always believe that life starts at conception. Protestant churches have different views on when life starts. Some believe that an embryo is not a life until it reaches a certain stage of development. Others believe the life starts at conception.
Protestant beliefs differ, so the details about stem cell research vary between churches. In some cases, the church takes a pro-life stance. In that situation, the church considers embryonic stem cell research a form of murder. A pro-choice stance allows for more flexibility. A pro-choice church usually considers an embryo a bundle of cells. They consider life to start at a later stage of development. Protestants may consider life to start when the brain stem forms. Others consider life to start when a fetus can feel pain, which is around 20 weeks.
Exact details in Protestant churches differ for each church. They may take a pro-life or a pro-choice approach to the idea of stem cell research. The key difference is the timing of when they consider life to start.
Religious views on stem cell research in the Muslim or Islamic communities depend on their specific ideas. In general, Islamic views on stem cell research do not take a pro-life approach. The key reason is Muslims believe the soul enters the body between 40 and 120 days after conception. The exact time frame depends on the specific school of thought within a Mosque.
Since they believe that the soul enters the body at 40 days or later, embryonic stem cells are not usually a religious concern. Some Muslims may have concerns about moral standards. They may also have concerns about the ethical standards of stem cell research. Their concerns relate to the morals of using embryos rather than the idea that it is a form of murder.
Jewish beliefs about stem cell research are like Muslim beliefs. They believe that the soul enters the body 40 days after conception. When scientists use the embryo before 40 days, a Jewish individual does not consider it a murder.
While they do not consider it a loss of a soul, a Jewish individual may consider it the loss of a potential life. He or she may also consider the process of obtaining embryonic stem cells unethical or immoral. The exact beliefs depend on the individual and their understanding of their religious practices.
The Moral Concerns
Religious stances on stem cell research depend on the belief system. Some religions consider the practice wrong in every instance. Their belief stems from the idea that life starts at conception. Other religions believe life starts after the soul enters the body. The exact timing depends on the religion, but it may range from a certain number of days to a certain number of months.
The view of embryonic stem cell research varies based on the religious group. Often, the primary factor is the basic idea of whether an individual is pro-life or pro-choice. It also depends on their view of when life starts in the womb.
John Hopkins Medicine invites Jeremy Sugarman M.D., M.P.H., M.A and Debra JH Matthews PhD, M.A. to get into more details about the ethical questions of stem cell research in this video:
Religious views on stem cell research vary for each religious group. The primary concern is religious groups may consider the termination of an embryo a form of murder. Timing also plays a role in the controversy. The stances on the topic depend on the religious group and may vary between different groups and practices.
What is your take on stem cell research? We would like to know your thoughts in the comments section below.